AB de Villiers absence spells danger for Test cricket, says Mike Brearley

This article is more than 3 years old

• World Cricket Committee says competitive levels must be maintained
• Stuart Broad revels in ‘fresh start’ with Joe Root against South Africa

Stuart Broad, who appears fit to play under his fifth England captain after recent heel trouble, takes part in a training session before the first Test against South Africa.
Stuart Broad, who appears fit to play under his fifth England captain after recent heel trouble, takes part in a training session before the first Test against South Africa. Photograph: Dan Mullan/Getty Images
Stuart Broad, who appears fit to play under his fifth England captain after recent heel trouble, takes part in a training session before the first Test against South Africa. Photograph: Dan Mullan/Getty Images

Last modified on Wed 21 Feb 2018 13.38 EST

AB de Villiers’ absence from the South Africa team at Lord’s this week has been called a “red flag” for Test cricket in a warning from the MCC World Cricket Committee about a looming crisis for the longest format amid the rise of domestic Twenty20 leagues.

De Villiers, the leading South African batsman of his generation, will not be a headache for England’s new captain, Joe Root, this Thursday as he is taking a sabbatical from facing the red ball. It began last year in a bid to manage his workload, and has recently been tipped to retire from Tests by the end of 2017.

The 33-year-old plays limited-overs international cricket and on the domestic Twenty20 circuit, leading the MCC World Cricket Committee chairman and former England captain, Mike Brearley, to describe his career choices as “symbolic of the problems” facing the sport.

Brearley, who has chaired the think tank since 2011 and now steps down from the role, also called on the International Cricket Council to press ahead with mooted plans for a world Test league, along with an “admittedly idealistic” plea for cricket boards to rethink the distribution of central funds in the world game.

“The game is facing – if not a crisis – a looming potential crisis,” said Brearley. “This crisis needs to be noticed and taken seriously. For international cricket to flourish, competitive levels need to be close and teams need to be able to field their best players.

“The committee is worried that with the spread of privately owned Twenty20 leagues and the rapid increase in remuneration, more players from counties lacking the funds to pay them well will choose these tournaments ahead of making themselves available for their countries.”

The former New Zealand captain Brendon McCullum was also on the committee and said De Villiers’s decision was “another red flag moment”. He added the caveat that, like his own choice to play on in Twenty20 after retirement, lifestyle issues could be at play too.

As the MCC panel voiced their concerns in the Lord’s media centre, the Root era began in earnest on the Nursery Ground as the bat-and-ball flea circus that is England’s pre-match training whirred into life under sunny London skies in preparation for the first Investec Test.

Stuart Broad, who was here on Saturday as part of Nottinghamshire’s victorious Royal London Cup side and appears fit to play after recent heel trouble, said there was a different feel to proceedings, in part down to the new leadership but also due to the six-month break since the tour of India that ended in a 4-0 defeat and preceded Alastair Cook stepping down.

“It does feel like a new era with Joe as captain,” said Broad. “With the change of leadership it’s an obvious fresh start. I don’t think I’ve had a gap like this playing for England, which is nice as well because it reminds you how special it is and how lucky you are to be a part of it. I’m lucky enough to have played over a hundred Tests but this feels like a debut.”

Broad’s last encounter with South Africa culminated in a trademark burst, as his six for 17 in Johannesburg in 2016 sealed a series win – the last major triumph of Cook’s four-year tenure. Root is now the fifth captain Broad has had to impress, having made his debut under Michael Vaughan in 2008 before spells under Kevin Pietersen and Andrew Strauss.

Broad said: “Vaughan was very much ‘you set your own fields’; Strauss was a little bit more ‘I’ll set the field’ and Cook was very happy with the bowlers taking responsibility. I think Joe will probably go down that route as well. He’s an attacking person and I’d expect us to put a lot of pressure on a new batsman. He’ll very much lead the way he plays his cricket.

“I think every captain I’ve played under has very much been part of the team because that’s when you really get honest feedback and communication is at its best. I know there’s been a lot of talk about whether it will affect his batting but he’s one of the best players in the world for a reason – he can really concentrate on whatever he’s doing at a certain time.”

Cook is now back among the rank and file and the early signs are that he has been freed up, England’s record run-scorer having shone for County Championship pacesetters Essex this summer with three centuries and an average of 66.7.

Broad said. “He’s absolutely loved being around the Essex changing room – it’s like when he was playing cricket as a kid, just for the love of playing cricket. He’s had quite a long period of the captaincy where there are different stresses, selection meetings etc. Now he just picks up his bat and plays. I think he’ll be extremely successful over the next couple of years.”

The selection issues for Root appear minimal for his first Test in the role. The one catch in a 12-man squad is whether to play Liam Dawson, a spin-bowling allrounder, or grant a debut to the Middlesex seamer Toby Roland-Jones on his home ground. Since the group was named last Friday, it has always pointed strongly towards the former.

In continuing on from the end of the India tour, Dawson’s tweak, along with that of Moeen Ali, would mean England fielding two spinners at Lord’s for the first time since 1993 – an innings and 62-run loss to Australia that saw Phil Tufnell and Peter Such share figures of four for 219.

To avoid talk of a “looming crisis” if ball doesn’t turn at Lord’s, it should be noted that Root, unlike Graham Gooch in that Ashes defeat, will still have four seamers at his disposal.